Revisiting 1932 with Oscar Straus’ “Eine Frau, die weiß was sie will”

Alexandra Ivanoff
Operetta Research Center
31 January, 2015

I can’t help it. I’m an addict. I’m hopelessly addicted to Komische Oper in Berlin. For me, as an American musician who was reared with the standard American musical diet (opera, symphony, Broadway musicals both old and new), there was no operetta across the Atlantic to speak of, except for the ubiquitous The Merry Widow and Die Fledermaus.

Journalist Alexandra Ivanoff (Photo: Privat)

Journalist Alexandra Ivanoff (Photo: Private)

In New York, I had lived for many years in The East Village, where pitiful few remnants of the bygone Yiddish vaudeville theatre existed, and the availability of seeing old films of the stars like Boris Tomashevsky, Molly Picon, and Fanny Brice was purely archival. A few brave and threadbare theatre companies in both New York and San Francisco (there, notably 42nd Street Moon) mounted semi-staged musicals from the 30s. They were a delight and a fascination, because of their comparatively innocent charm to what came to the musical theatre stages in the 70s.

One of my many “Joe jobs,” as we called the many part-time wage-slave gigs to supplement a free-lance musical existence in the Big Apple, was working in the famous Patelson Music House behind Carnegie Hall. Owner Joseph Patelson had begun that business by buying estates of music scores which he re-sold to the public. Several of the shelves were devoted to huge collections of sheet music, including complete sets of songs from American musicals from the ‘teens, ‘20s and ‘30s. With my meager earnings, I bought as many as I possibly could, amassing a healthy collection of original sheet music by the Gershwins, Cole Porter, Irving Berlin, Jerome Kern, and many more. I treasure this music like it’s gold. Not only is it history, it’s wonderful music.

It speaks of life almost 100 years ago in a New York that was imbued with a European accent from the hundreds of thousands of immigrants.

Fast forward to September 2014, when I made the decision to transplant myself to Berlin after nearly eight years in Istanbul, where I had established myself as a music journalist in several publications and taught singing in my private studio. It was only the jazz students who had heard of some of these old songs (they’re called “standards” in the jazz world) but they had no idea of their origin. I longed to step into my Time Machine to travel back to the 1920s in Europe, to witness this music in real time.

Alexandra Ivanoff and her friend Yvonne Kálmán in Budapest.

Alexandra Ivanoff and her friend Yvonne Kálmán in Budapest.

Budapest, a city with an atmosphere of faded Belle Epoque elegance, was near the top of my list of possible new places to live. But despite Hungarians’ devotion to their native composers’ music, including operetta, this slightly dusty jewel of a city on the Danube lost out to Berlin, for reasons that have to do with a sense of expanding opportunity. I’m glad I trusted my gut, because Berlin has the Komische Oper! Since this company has been in the magic hands of Barrie Kosky, who has understood my craving to be transported back in time with the energy of a heat-seeking missile, the Komische Oper is the place that feeds my century-old soul.

Oscar Straus’ 1932 novelty resurrected

Scene from "Eine Frau, die weiß was sie will". (Photo: Iko Freese

Dagmar Manzel and Max Hopp in a scene from “Eine Frau, die weiß was sie will”. (Photo: Iko Freese

On Jan. 30, I saw the premiere of the 1932 musical comedy Eine Frau, die weiss, was sie will! (A woman who knows what she wants!) by Oscar Straus (1870-1954), a composer, who like Emmerich Kalman, chronicled in music and theatre so much of society’s transition from one century to the next. This production is the first since its original premiere 83 years ago with the same company.

One of those quantum leaps in public mores was the emancipation of women from hausfrau to public figure. In the case of this 90-minute musical, the titular reference describes, via superbly comic stratagems, a woman’s right to have affairs on an equal playing field to men’s historical entitlements in the l’amour department.

With a text by Alfred Grünwald and based on Mademoiselle ma mère (1920) by Louis Verneuill, the show has a tour-de-force trajectory with only two people playing multiple roles. And not just a few: Dagmar Manzel plays six, including the glamorous Manon Cavallini, the central plot figure. Max Hopp plays a total of 12 characters in a dizzying, brashly vaudeville style staging with lightning-speed costume changes, gags which included hilarious speech defects and a plethora of bon mots, door-slamming schtick, and plenty of gender-bending cross-dressing – even hybrid tuxedo/gown creations.

One of the many cross-dressing moments: Dagmar Manzel and Max Hopp in a scene from "Eine Frau, die weiß was sie will". (Photo: Iko Freese

One of the many cross-dressing moments: Dagmar Manzel and Max Hopp in a scene from “Eine Frau, die weiß was sie will”. (Photo: Iko Freese

To say that these two performers are amazing is understated; what they do, non-stop, is simply incredible in their physically demanding duo dynamic which undoubtedly recalls the heydey of vaudeville’s hellz-a-poppin’ atmosphere. But in this case, the antics are accompanied by a superb melody-rich song score that sported such sublime phrases as “It’s no coincidence that a rose has a perfume” and “Every woman has a secret longing in her heart for a sweet and forbidden kiss” (one of the more serious and melancholic moments), and supported by an orchestra so ably led by music director Adam Benzwi, who also inhabits every nuance of the production (based on my close observation of his performance).

Nota bene: I was delighted that the costume-change crew from backstage stepped out to receive their highly deserved applause. Without them, this stopwatch-speed production couldn’t happen.

The premiere on Jan. 30 was preceded by an especially moving ceremony in front of the main entrance of the Komische Oper building, where three “Stolpersteine” were planted in in the sidewalk next to the front steps. These cobblestone-sized brass memorial stones join the tens of thousands of such Stolpersteine in Germany, and serve to memorialize victims of the Holocaust. Komische Oper’s stones were inscribed with the names of Fritz Spira, Kuba Reichmann, and Hans Schapira, all of whom worked in various capacities at the Metropole Theatre, the original building of the Komische Oper. As Kosky remarked at a post-show reception, “These Stolpersteine are [also] one of the best ways to remember this music, and the time in which this music was forbidden.”

Laying down the "Stolpersteine" in Behrenstraße. (Photo: Komische Oper Berlin.)

Laying down the “Stolpersteine” in Behrenstraße. (Photo: Komische Oper Berlin.)

All images by Iko Freese are from (Agentur für Theaterfotos).

There is one comment

  1. Richard Norton

    London saw this as MOTHER OF PEARL with Alice DeLysia. Thematically similar to BALL IM SAVOY, it’s obsessed with love, betrayal and a happy resolution. Intendant Barrie Kosky radically re-thought the work as a two-person vaudeville, with two superstars, Dagmar Manzel and Max Hopp playing 21 different male and female parts in a series of quick-change costumes and scenes. Set was a plain door and pair of sconces, copied from the interior of the Komische Oper ground floor, all framed by a huge red curtain. However the full Komische Oper orchestra played the original orchestrations which were a joy to hear. The madcap tone was set at the outset with both stars as grumpy old men admirers of diva star Manon Cavallini, then instantly transforming the strapping 6-foot Hopp into a pink satin dress and blond wig, and the shorter Manzel into a Harpo Marx-like man’s tuxedo with mustache and cigar. At times each were left/right sides male/female, flipping character from side to side. I haven’t seen anything to match it since Charles Ludlam’s MYSTERY OF IRMA VEP. Thank God for the English translation on the back of the seat in front of me, and the plot synopsis in the program, or I’d have been lost. And the Straus score is a treasure to discover, be it the familiar “Every Woman Thinks She Wants to Wander” from MOTHER OF PEARL or other familiar tunes. The finale medley made me want to hear the score again and again, and the audience response was tremendous, another big success for Barrie Kosky and the Komische Oper. It will be repeated only 5 times this season; at the after-party Kosky announced that Hopp will star as Henry Higgins in next season’s MY FAIR LADY at the Komische Oper.